What can happen to a body, and what each choice involves
There are fewer decisions here than the volume of paperwork suggests. The body is buried, cremated, donated, or handled by one of the newer processes some states now permit. Each of those has a simple form and an elaborate form, and the elaborate form is optional. Embalming is not routinely required by any state law. What is available to you depends significantly on where you are: natural burial, home burial, alkaline hydrolysis and natural organic reduction are permitted in some states and not others, and cemeteries impose their own requirements independently of the law.
Why it exists
Every culture has had to answer the same practical question, and the answers have always been shaped by land, climate, law and belief together. The modern American funeral industry standardized one particular answer during the twentieth century, which is why many families assume that embalming, a viewing and a sealed casket are what a funeral is. They are options.
Knowing the full range matters financially and emotionally. The gap in cost between the simplest and the most elaborate handling of the same body is very large, and families who do not know the range often assume they are choosing between what they were shown and nothing at all.
It also matters because the person may have said what they wanted. A stated preference for cremation, for a natural burial, or for donation is much easier to honor when the family knows what those things involve before the conversation with the funeral director rather than during it.
How it actually works
Burial is placement of the body in the ground or in a vault or mausoleum. It usually involves a casket, a burial plot, an opening and closing fee charged by the cemetery, and often an outer burial container required by the cemetery rather than by law. Immediate burial, which happens shortly after death without embalming or a preceding ceremony, is an option every provider must offer, and a memorial service can be held later.
Cremation reduces the body by heat, returning fragments that are processed and given to the family. Direct cremation, without embalming, viewing or a prior ceremony, is likewise an option every provider must offer, and providers offering cremation must make alternative containers available rather than requiring a casket. Cremation does not preclude a service. It changes only when the service happens.
Natural or green burial is burial without embalming, in a biodegradable container, generally without a vault or liner. Massachusetts, for example, defines a green burial as one where the body is not embalmed, no metal or hardwood is used in the casket, and no gravel liner or vault is used. Whether it is available near you depends on the cemetery, because most conventional cemeteries require a liner as a matter of their own policy.
Home burial and the newer processes are the most state dependent of all. Massachusetts permits home burial on private residential land, but requires written approval from the local board of health and from the local governing body, a site plan filed with the Registry of Deeds, and review by the state environmental agency. Alkaline hydrolysis, sometimes described as water cremation, and natural organic reduction, sometimes described as human composting, are lawful in some states and not in others, and the list changes as legislatures act. Ask your own state's funeral board or health department what is currently permitted where you are.
Where you stand
You are entitled to the simple version of any option. Direct cremation and immediate burial exist precisely so that a family can decline embalming, viewing and a preceding ceremony without declining a dignified handling of the body.
You are entitled to hold a service separately from the disposition. Nothing requires a funeral to happen before a burial or a cremation, and separating them removes almost all of the time pressure that makes early decisions expensive.
You are entitled to ask a cemetery for its rules in writing. Vault requirements, headstone specifications, and what may be planted are cemetery policy rather than law, and a cemetery that will not put its requirements in writing is telling you something.
Availability varies by state and sometimes by county. Home burial, natural burial grounds, alkaline hydrolysis and natural organic reduction all depend on state law and local permitting. The authoritative answer comes from your state funeral board, your state health department, or the local board of health, not from a national article.
What to do
The mistakes that cost people
- Assuming a vault is required by law. It is usually a cemetery policy, and cemeteries differ.
- Believing cremation rules out a service. It changes the order of events and nothing else.
- Buying a casket before asking whether an alternative container is acceptable, particularly where cremation is planned.
- Relying on a national article for what is legal in your state. Disposition law is state law, and the newer processes are being legislated on continually.
Words you will meet
- disposition
- The final handling of the body: burial, cremation, donation, or another process the state permits.
- embalming
- A chemical process that temporarily delays decomposition, not required as a routine matter by any state law.
- alternative container
- An unfinished wood, cardboard or composite container used for cremation in place of a casket, which providers offering cremation must make available.
- natural burial
- Burial without embalming, in a biodegradable container, generally without a vault or grave liner.
- alkaline hydrolysis
- A water and alkali based process that reduces the body to bone fragments and liquid, lawful in some states and not others.
- natural organic reduction
- A controlled process that converts the body into soil, lawful in some states and not others.
What this does not cover
This module does not cover whole body donation to a medical school, which is in the Body and the End of Life discipline, or burial in a national cemetery for veterans, which is in Money, Benefits and Insurance. It also does not list which states permit which newer processes, because that list changes and a stale list would be worse than none.
Go deeper
These are the primary sources. When in doubt, trust them over anyone, including us.
- Federal Trade Commission: The FTC Funeral RuleConfirms that direct cremation and immediate burial must be offered, that alternative containers must be available, and that routine embalming is not legally required.opens in a new tab
- Federal Trade Commission: Shopping for funeral servicesHow to compare the cost of each form of disposition across providers, and what the categories on a price list mean.opens in a new tab
- Massachusetts Department of Public Health: Information for local boards of health on home burials and green burialsAn example of how one state defines and permits home and green burial. Use it as a model for what to ask your own state, not as authority outside Massachusetts.opens in a new tab
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Where to write for vital recordsThe route to each state's vital records office, which is generally the same department that can point you to burial and disposition permitting.opens in a new tab
- Federal Trade Commission: Complying with the Funeral RuleWhat providers are required to offer and disclose about each form of disposition, in the industry's own compliance language.opens in a new tab
Every situation is different from the last.
Get a path made for you